Anthony
The Brooklinen Down Pillow is plush and inviting, providing an ultrasoft cradle for your head and neck. For side or back sleepers, a more supportive design is available. The pillow also feels cool, as the cotton sateen shell minimizes heat retention compared to other down-filled models we’ve tested.
How It Performed
Our testers evaluated all three density levels of the Brooklinen Down Pillow. The Plush pillow is the softest option, providing significant sinkage and minimal neck strain for stomach sleepers. For side sleepers, we recommend the Firm pillow due to its high loft. Back sleepers gave the highest ratings to the Mid-Plush feel, which offers a balance between soft cushioning and strong support, making it suitable for a wide range of sleepers.Each density level features a different construction, but all three pillows are highly moldable and snuggly. The chambered design helps maintain a full shape, though Brooklinen recommends daily fluffing to evenly distribute the fill. While the down retains some heat, the breathable cover promotes cooling, and none of our testers found the pillows to be overly warm.
Pros
Three firmness options to suit different sleeper preferences.
Down and feather clusters with a cotton sateen shell ensure a soft, cloud-like feel.
Each order comes with a trial period spanning an entire year.
Cons:
Fill may trigger down allergies.
Pillow should not be machine washed.
What It’s Made of
Each of the three Brooklinen Down Pillows has a unique construction. The Plush pillow contains only down, offering an exceptionally soft surface for your head and neck. The Mid-Plush pillow features feather cores with down outer chambers, providing excellent cushioning without excessive sinkage thanks to the support of the feathers. The Firm pillow also has a chambered design, but with a higher ratio of feathers to elevate your head even further, making it ideal for those who need more support.
These pillows are encased in silky-smooth cotton covers. To maintain the integrity of the down and feathers, it’s recommended to spot clean the pillow if stains occur, though dry cleaning is another option. They are available in standard and king sizes.The Brooklinen Down Pillow is reasonably priced, with discounts available when ordering two or four pillows. Shipping is free for all customers in the contiguous U.S. Brooklinen offers a 365-night sleep trial, one of the longest in the industry, and an additional year of warranty coverage against structural defects.
Highlights
Plush fill creates a cloud-like surface for the head and neck.
Available in three designs to accommodate different sleep positions and firmness preferences.
All orders include a 365-night sleep trial.
How Does It Feel?
The “Plush” pillow, designed for stomach sleepers, is the softest option. It contains pure down clusters that compress deeply, providing adequate support without overly elevating the neck. Back sleepers will likely find the “Mid-Plush” down-and-feather pillow most comfortable, as it offers a bit of loft to keep the head and neck aligned with the spine. For side sleepers, the “Firm” design is recommended. This pillow, which also contains a blend of down and feathers, is the densest and most supportive option, ensuring ample cushioning between the head and the downward-facing shoulder.
All three designs feel relatively soft, with the cotton sateen shell enhancing this softness. The cotton is also exceptionally breathable. The pure down fill of the Plush pillow creates a particularly cloud-like feel, while the two firmer designs offer more support due to the feathers in their base chambers. To maintain the pillow, spot clean any stains and dry clean a couple of times per year, as machine washing can cause permanent damage. Investing in a pillowcase or protector is advisable for easier care and added longevity.
Why We Like It
Versatility is one of the Brooklinen Down Pillow’s standout features. Each density level offers a unique feel, allowing you to select from three designs based on your sleep position and firmness preferences. Temperature control is another strong point. While down typically absorbs heat, making pillows feel overly warm, the breathable cotton sateen cover effectively offsets this, helping you stay comfortable. Additionally, the highly moldable nature of down makes the pillow great for snuggling or tucking between your legs.
Shoppers who purchase multiple pillows can receive a discount of up to 15%. Brooklinen provides free ground delivery for all Down Pillow orders within the contiguous U.S. and competitive shipping rates for customers in Alaska, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico. The company’s 365-night sleep trial is one of the longest available among online bedding retailers. If you decide to keep the pillow after the trial period, you’ll also receive an additional year of warranty coverage.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the Brooklinen Down Pillow stands out as a versatile and luxurious option for discerning sleepers. With three firmness options available, tailored to suit various sleeper preferences, this pillow caters to a wide range of needs. The blend of down and feather clusters, combined with a cotton sateen shell, delivers a soft and cloud-like feel that promotes comfort and relaxation. Additionally, each order includes a generous trial period lasting an entire year, allowing customers ample time to determine if the pillow meets their expectations and sleep needs.
While the Brooklinen Down Pillow offers exceptional comfort and support, it’s important to note that the down fill may trigger allergies in some individuals. Additionally, machine washing is not recommended for this pillow, necessitating alternative cleaning methods. Overall, with its premium construction, customizable firmness options, and generous trial period, the Brooklinen Down Pillow emerges as a top contender in the realm of luxury bedding, providing an indulgent sleep experience for those seeking superior comfort and quality.
